HEALTH & WELFARE POOL
GENERAL ASSESSMENT FORMULA
FOR THE
PURMS JOINT SELF-INSURANCE AGREEMENT
Amended and Restated
as of December 7, 2001
Overview of Assessment Formulas for PURMS Risk Pools
The “Assessment Formulas” Sections of the PURMS Joint
Self-Insurance Agreement (“SIA”) set forth the formulas for assessing the
Members of each Risk Pool for the Operational Costs the Fund incurs in operating
their respective Risk Pools, including without limitation, Coverage Payments
(all Risk Pools), Defense Costs (Liability Pool), Property Claim Costs
(Property Pool), Direct H&W Claims Costs and Shared H&W Costs (H&W
Pool), and the Direct and Shared Administrative Expenses of all Risk Pools.
The Liability Pool is governed by two Assessment Formulas, one
for General Assessments and one for Premium Assessments. The two current formulas for the Liability
Pool are:
(a)
The Liability General Assessment Formula (with Annual
Assessment Limit) (SIA § VIII); and
(b)
The Liability Premium Assessment Formula (with Added-Risk
Pass Through, and without Annual
Assessment Limit) (SIA § IX).
The Liability General Assessment Formula was first adopted by the
Members of the Fund on December 20. 1976, has been amended from time to time,
and was unanimously re-adopted on March
30, 1995. The Liability Premium Assessment Formula (with Added-Risk
Pass Through and without Annual Assessment Limit) was unanimously re-adopted by
the Board at its General Meeting on December
9, 1994, effective January
1, 1995.
The Property Pool is also governed by two Assessment Formulas,
one for General Assessments and one for Premium Assessments. The two current formulas for the Property
Pool are:
(a)
The Property General Assessment Formula (with Annual
Assessment Limit) (SIA § XII); and
(b)
The Property Premium Assessment Formula (without Annual
Assessment Limit) (SIA § XIII). The
H&W Risk Pool is currently governed by one Assessment Formula entitled the
H&W General Assessment Formula (SIA § XV).
The Property General Assessment and the Property Premium
Assessment Formulas were unanimously adopted by the Members of the Fund
effective February 27, 1997.
Assessments of Members of the H&W Pool are governed by a
single Assessment Formula called the H&W General Assessment Formula. (SIA §
XV). This Formula covers both the self-insured portion of the H&W Pool’s
Operational Costs as well as the cost of Stop Loss Insurance. The H&W
General Assessment Formula was unanimously adopted by the Members of the Fund
on March 16, 2000,
effective April 1, 2000,
and was amended and restated and unanimously re-adopted by the Members as of December 7, 2001.
These Formulas, as amended from time to time
pursuant to § I, § 5.2, are specifically incorporated into the
Interlocal Agreement and shall be deemed a part of that Agreement as if fully
set forth therein.
HEALTH & WELFARE GENERAL
ASSESSMENT FORMULA
1.
Definitions For H&W
General Assessment Formula. The
Definitions set forth in the “Definitions” Section of the SIA (§ II) apply
to the interpretation of the Fund's Assessment Formulas, except as may be
modified specifically or by necessary implication by the Definitions set forth
below which are specific to this H&W General Assessment Formula Section.
1.1.
Allowed H&W Claim--shall
mean an H&W Claim which is not within the terms of an H&W Pool Member’s
Coverage Booklet, but which is paid by the H&W Pool according to § XV,
¶¶ 5.2.2.2 and 5.2.3.
1.2.
Alternate ISL Method--shall
mean the secondary method for determining a Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point
if such Stop Loss Point, calculated under the Primary ISL Method in §XV, ¶
3.2.4.1, does not satisfy the Primary ISL Method Cross Check set forth in
§ XV, ¶ 3.2.4.2.
1.3.
Assessment Formula--with
respect to the H&W Pool, shall mean the Formula for calculating a Member’s
Monthly H&W Assessment, which consists of a Member’s Direct H&W Claims
Costs paid by the H&W Pool in the preceding month and such Member’s H&W
Assessment Share of Shared H&W Costs determined under the H&W General
Assessment Formula (§ XV).
1.1.
Average Claims Frequency Ratio--shall
mean the average of all H&W Members’ Claims Frequency Ratios, as provided
in § XV, ¶ 2.1(a).
1.2.
Benefits Check--shall
mean a check issued by the Administrator for the H&W Pool to a Medical
Provider to pay for Medical Services provided to an Eligible Employee or
Dependent.
1.3.
Claims Experience--shall
mean a Member’s or potential New Member’s experience regarding the amounts and
frequency of Health & Welfare Benefits claims for its Employees and
Dependents.
1.4.
Claims Frequency Factor--shall
mean the percentage that a Member’s Claims Frequency Ratio is to the total of
all Claims Frequency Ratios of all H&W Pool Members. A Member’s Claims Frequency Factor is used to
weight a Member’s 30% Formula Component relating to its H&W Claims
Experience based on the frequency of such Member’s H&W Claims in relation
to the frequency of the H&W Claims of all H&W Pool Members. (see § XV, ¶ 2.1).
1.5.
Claims Frequency Ratio--shall
mean the Ratio resulting from dividing the total of all Benefits Checks issued
by the H&W Pool to Medical Providers for each Member’s Eligible Employees
and Dependents in the preceding month by the total number of each Member’s
Eligible Employees in the preceding month, as provided in § XV,
¶ 2.1(b).
1.6.
Covered H&W Claim--shall
mean an H&W Claim for which H&W Coverage is provided to an Eligible
Employee (or Dependent) under the terms of the applicable Coverage Booklet and
the SIA.
1.7.
Date of Membership--shall
mean the date a Member of the Fund becomes a Member of a particular Risk Pool.
1.8.
Debatable H&W Claims--shall
mean an H&W Claim for which H&W Coverage is neither clearly provided
for, nor clearly precluded, by the terms of a Member’s Coverage Booklet and the
SIA (see § XV, ¶ 5).
1.9.
Dependent Coverage--shall
mean H&W Coverage provided for Medical Services rendered to an Eligible
Employee’s Dependents, as that term is defined in the applicable Coverage
Booklet.
1.10.
Dependents--shall
mean, without limitation, an Employee’s spouse or children or other dependents
eligible for H&W Coverage, as determined by the terms in the applicable
Coverage Booklet.
1.11.
Direct H&W Claims Costs--shall
mean the dollar amount of a Member’s H&W Claims Costs which does not
qualify for treatment as “Shared H&W Claims”, and which is passed through
directly to a Member on a monthly basis as part of the Member’s Monthly H&W
Assessment.
1.12.
Eligible Employee--shall
mean an Employee who is enrolled by the Member with the Administrator for the
H&W Pool as entitled to receive H&W Coverage for Medical Services, as
determined by the terms of the applicable Coverage Booklet and the SIA.
1.13.
Eligible Employee Assessment
Allocation--shall mean the dollar amount of the Formula Component of
a Member’s H&W Assessment Share of 70% of the Shared H&W Cost based on
the number of the Member’s Eligible Employees in relation to the number of
Eligible Employees of all H&W Pool Members, as determined under the H&W
General Assessment Formula, (see § XV, ¶ 2.2).
1.14.
Eligible Employee Factor--shall
mean the percentage of an H&W Pool Member’s Eligible Employees in relation
the number of Eligible Employees of all Members, (see § XV,
¶ 2.2(a)).
1.15.
Eligible Insured--shall
mean either an Eligible Employee of a Member or a Dependent of an Eligible
Employee entitled to H&W Coverage through a Member according to the terms
of such Member’s Coverage Booklet. The
“Eligible Insureds” of a Member shall be all Eligible Employees and Dependents
of such Member.
1.16.
Employee--with respect
to the H&W Pool, shall mean the Employee of a Member of the H&W Pool,
and unless otherwise inconsistent in the context, shall include such Employee’s
Dependents, as determined by the terms of the applicable Coverage Booklet.
1.17.
Employee Demographic Categories--shall
mean the three weighted risk categories that are used in connection with the
H&W General Assessment Formula to establish the amount of a Member’s
Aggregate Stop Loss and a Member’s Individual Stop Loss. The three categories consist of (a) an Eligible
Employee, (b) an Eligible Employee and one Dependent, and (c) an Eligible
Employee and 2 or more Dependents, as provided more specifically in § XV,
¶ 3.2.3.
1.18.
Employee Demographics--shall
mean the number or percentage of Eligible Employees and/or Dependents for each
Member, verses the H&W Pool as a whole, with respect to each of the
Employee Demographic Categories.
1.19.
Fund’s Fiscal Year--shall
mean the annual accounting year for the Fund, which shall be the calendar year,
unless otherwise determined by Majority Vote of the Board.
1.20.
H&W Assessments--shall
mean any and all Assessments issued by the H&W Pool to its Members.
1.21.
H&W Assessment Share--shall
mean the amount of money a Member of the H&W Pool becomes obligated to pay
the H&W Pool on a monthly basis for Shared H&W Costs paid in the
preceding month, as determined by the H&W General Assessment Formula. A Member’s H&W Assessment Share, together
with its Direct H&W Claims Costs from the preceding month, shall comprise a
Member’s Monthly H&W Assessment.
1.22.
H&W Claim--shall
mean a claim submitted by or on behalf of an Eligible Employee (or Dependent)
arising from the rendering of Medical Services to an Eligible Employee (or
Dependent) by a Medical Provider.
1.23.
H&W Claims Costs--shall
mean the total dollar amount the H&W Pool paid to Medical Providers in the
preceding month for Covered H&W Claims made by a Member’s Eligible
Employees and their Dependents.
1.24.
H&W Claims Experience--shall
mean the total dollar amount of H&W Claims paid by the H&W Pool on
behalf of a Member.
1.25.
H&W Claims Experience
Assessment Allocation--shall mean the dollar amount of the Formula
Component of a Member’s H&W Assessment Share of 30% of the Shared H&W
Costs based on the Member’s H&W Claims Experience in relation to the
H&W Claims Experience of all H&W Pool Members, weighted by the Member’s
Claims Utilization Frequency Factor as determined under the H&W General
Assessment Formula (see § XV, ¶ 2.1).
1.26.
H&W Coverage--shall
mean the insurance coverage provided by the H&W Pool for Health &
Welfare Benefits and Medical Services
provided to each Member’s Eligible Employees and Dependents, in accordance with
each Member’s Coverage Booklet and the terms of the SIA.
1.27.
H&W General Assessment
Formula--shall mean the General Assessment Formula for the H&W
Risk Pool, set forth in § XV.
1.28.
H&W Pool--shall
mean the Risk Pool operated by the Fund that provides protection to its
Members’ Eligible Employees and Dependents for Heath & Welfare Benefits, as
specified in Members’ respective Coverage Booklets.
1.29.
H&W Pool Aggregate Stop
Loss--shall mean the total dollar amount of established by contact
with the Stop Loss Carrier at which any further payments by the H&W Pool
for the H&W Claims of any and all Members are thereafter covered by Stop
Loss Insurance.
1.30.
H&W Pool Individual Stop
Loss--shall mean the dollar amount that is established by contact
with the Stop Loss Carrier at which any further payments the H&W Pool would
otherwise make in connection with a particular H&W Claim and/or an Eligible
Employee or Dependent, or on some other basis established by the Stop Loss
Carrier, are instead covered by Stop Loss Insurance, even though the H&W
Pool’s Aggregate Stop Loss has not been reached.
1.31.
H&W Pool Operational Costs--shall
mean all of the expenses the Fund incurs with respect to operation of the
H&W Pool, including without limitation, Direct and Shared Administrative
Expenses, Broker, Legal and Accounting fees, PPO Charges, Stop Loss Insurance
Premiums, Shared H&W Claims and Direct H&W Claims Costs.
1.32.
Incurred--shall
mean, with respect to an H&W Claim, shall mean the date that Medical
Services were provided to an Eligible Employee or Dependent.
1.33.
Member Aggregate Stop Loss--shall
mean the total dollar amount at which any further payments by the H&W Pool
on H&W Claims by a Member’s Eligible Employees or Dependents shall
constitute Shared H&W Claims and shall be reimbursed to the H&W Pool by
Assessment of all Members (except for the Member that has reached its Aggregate
Stop Loss) under the H&W General Assessment Formula, rather than being
passed through to the Member as Direct H&W Claims Costs. The amount of each Member’s Aggregate Stop
Loss shall be determined in accordance with § XV, ¶ 3.2.3.
1.34.
Member Individual Stop Loss--shall
mean the dollar amount at which any further payments by the H&W Pool on a
particular H&W Claim or for an Eligible Employee or Dependent, or on some
of other basis established by the Stop Loss Carrier, shall constitute a “Shared
H&W Claim” and shall be reimbursed to the H&W Pool by Assessment of all
Members (except for the Member that has reached its Individual Stop Loss) under
the H&W General Assessment Formula, rather than being passed through to the
Member as Direct H&W Claims Costs. The
amount of each Member’s Individual Stop Loss shall be determined in accordance
with § XV, ¶ 3.2.4.
1.35.
Monthly H&W Assessment--shall
mean the Assessment issued by the Administrator on a monthly basis to each
Member (and as applicable, Former Member) of the H&W Pool to replenish such
Members’ Initial Deposit which, as to each Member, shall consist of the
Member’s Assessment Share of the total amount of all Members’ Shared H&W
Costs paid in the preceding month, in an amount determined by the H&W
General Assessment Formula, and the total amount of that Member’s Direct
H&W Claims Costs paid in the preceding month.
1.36.
Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop
Loss Point--shall mean the point at which the total of all Covered
H&W Claims and all Pool Recognized H&W Claims equal the H&W Pool’s
Aggregate Stop Loss.
1.37.
Pool Recognized H&W Claims--shall
mean all H&W Claims where the H&W Coverage for such claim is reasonably
debatable, as determined by the Administrative Committee, and which the
Administrative Committee determines should be recognized by the H&W Pool
for payment and for accrual toward the Member’s Stop Loss Points and the Pool
Recognized Stop Loss Point.
1.38.
Post-Stop-Loss H&W
Assessments--shall mean those portions of Member’s Monthly H&W
Assessments relating to the H&W Pool paying Post-Stop-Loss H&W Claims,
which shall be refunded to Members when and to the extent the H&W Pool has
been reimbursed by the Stop Loss Carrier, as provided in § I,
¶¶ 4.2.2 and 4.2.3.
1.39.
Post-Stop-Loss H&W Claims--shall
mean the total dollar amount paid by the H&W Pool on H&W Claims after
the H&W Pool reached the Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss Point.
1.40.
PPO Charges--shall
mean the additional expenses incurred by the H&W Pool for the services
provided by a preferred provider organization which shall be treated as a
Shared H&W Cost under the H&W General Assessment Formula.
1.41.
Primary ISL Method--shall
mean the preferred method for calculating an H&W Pool Member’s Individual
Stop Loss Point, as provided in §XV, ¶ 3.2.4.1.
1.42.
Primary ISL Method Cross Check--shall
mean the calculations set forth in §XV, ¶ 3.2.4.2 requiring the dollar amount
of the Member’s Individual Stop Loss (calculated pursuant to the Primary ISL
Method) to be multiplied times the number of that Member’s Eligible Employees
to determine if the resulting number is equal to or greater than such Members’
Aggregate Stop Loss. If so, then the
Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point shall be that calculated under the Primary
ISL Method. If not, then the Alternative
ISL Method in §XV, ¶ 3.2.4.3 shall be applied.
1.43.
Prior Monthly H&W Claims
Experience--shall mean the monthly average of the total cost of the
Claims an Initial H&W Member or a New H&W Member experienced for a
Health & Welfare Benefits package for its Employees, similar to the
Benefits package proposed for H&W Coverage by the H&W Pool, in the most
recent consecutive twelve (12) months preceding the date of the application,
provided that the last month of said 12 consecutive months does not end more
than 3 months prior to the Date of Membership.
1.44.
Prior Monthly H&W Premium--shall
mean the most recent monthly premium the Initial H&W Member or a New
H&W Member paid prior to the Date of Membership in the H&W Pool for a
Health & Welfare Benefits package for its Employees similar to the package
proposed for H&W Coverage by the H&W Pool.
1.45.
Recognized H&W Claim--shall
mean either a “Stop Loss Recognized Claim” (see § XV, ¶ 5.2.1)
or a “Pool Recognized H&W Claim” (see § XV, ¶ 5.2.2.1).
1.46. Shared
H&W Claims--shall mean the amount of a Member’s H&W Claims Costs
paid by the H&W Pool in the preceding month that exceeded either the
Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss or the Member’s Individual Stop Loss, and which
are not covered by Stop Loss Insurance.
Shared H&W Claims are paid as Shared H&W Costs to be reimbursed
by the Members of the H&W Pool under the H&W General Assessment
Formula.
1.47.
Shared H&W Costs--shall
mean all of the H&W Pool Operational Costs except for a Member’s Direct
H&W Claims Costs. Shared H&W Costs
shall include, without limitation, Administrative Expenses allocable to the
H&W Pool, premiums for Stop Loss Insurance, PPO Charges and Shared H&W
Claims, paid by the H&W Pool in or otherwise allocable to the preceding
month. All Shared H&W Costs shall be
assessed to Members of the H&W Pool under the H&W General Assessment
Formula.
1.48.
Stop Loss Carrier--shall
mean the insurance company that provides Stop Loss Insurance for the H&W
Pool and its Members.
1.49.
Stop Loss Coverage--shall
mean the coverage provided by the Stop Loss Insurance.
1.50.
Stop Loss Insurance--shall
mean the coverage provided by a Stop Loss Carrier to the H&W Pool and its
Members that begins paying H&W Claims Costs at either the H&W Pool
Aggregate Stop Loss or the H&W Pool Individual Stop Loss.
1.51.
Stop Loss Point--with
respect to a Member, shall mean the dollar amount at which a Member ceases
being directly responsible under its Monthly H&W Assessment for payments on
a particular H&W Claim or for a particular Eligible Employee or Dependent
(i.e. the Member Individual Stop Loss Point), or on all H&W Claims
submitted by or made on behalf of all of the Member’s Eligible Employees and
Dependents (i.e. the Member Aggregate Stop Loss Points), and further payments
thereon are assessed as Shared H&W Claims under the H&W General
Assessment Formula;
--with respect to the H&W Pool,
shall mean the dollar amount at which the H&W Pool ceases being responsible
for payments made on a particular H&W Claim or for a particular Eligible
Employee or Dependent (i.e. the H&W Pool Individual Stop Loss Point), or for any further payments made on any
further H&W Claims by the Eligible Employees and Dependents of any Member
(i.e. the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss Point), and further payments thereon
are covered by Stop Loss Insurance.
1.52.
Stop Loss Policy Year--shall
mean the annual or other period of time covering the effective dates of the
Stop Loss Insurance.
1.53.
Stop Loss Insurance Premium--shall
mean the dollar amount paid by the H&W Pool for Stop Loss Insurance,
monthly or annually, or otherwise.
1.54.
Stop Loss Recognized H&W
Claims--shall mean those H&W Claims that the Stop Loss Carrier
counts towards satisfaction of the H&W Pool Aggregate or Individual Stop
Loss Points.
2.
Statement of H&W General
Assessment Formula and Calculation of a Member’s Monthly H&W Assessment. The H&W General Assessment Formula shall
have two (2) Formula Components (a Member’s H&W Claims Experience
Assessment Allocation and the Member’s Eligible Employee Assessment Allocation)
which shall be applied to the total of the Shared H&W Costs paid by the
H&W Pool in, or otherwise allocable to, the preceding month of the H&W
Pool’s operations. Shared H&W Costs
are all expenses of operating the H&W Pool (i.e., the H&W Pool
Operational Costs), but excluding Direct H&W Claims Costs which are passed
through to the Member. The total of each
Member’s H&W Claims Experience Assessment Allocation and its Eligible
Employee Assessment Allocation shall constitute each Member’s H&W Assessment
Share of such Shared H&W Costs. A
Member’s H&W Assessment Share, together with the amount of such Member’s
Direct H&W Claims Costs incurred in the preceding month, shall comprise
such Member’s Monthly H&W Assessment.
A Member’s
H&W Assessment Share of the Shared H&W Costs under the H&W General
Assessment Formula shall be determined as follows:
2.1 H&W Claims Experience Assessment Allocation at 30%. Thirty percent (30%) of the amount of the
Shared H&W Costs paid in, or otherwise allocable to, the preceding month of
H&W Pool operations shall be assessed to the H&W Pool Members under the
H&W General Assessment Formula based on the relative Claims Frequency
Factors derived from each Member’s H&W Claims Experience in the preceding
month. The Formula steps for deriving
this Formula Component are as follows:
(a)
First, the Average Claims Frequency Ratio shall be
determined for the H&W Pool by taking the total of all Benefits Checks
issued to Medical Providers for all Members’ Eligible Employees and Dependants
in the preceding month and dividing that total by the total number of Eligible
Employees (not including Dependents) of all Members in the preceding month.
(b)
Second, the Claims Frequency Ratio for each Member
shall be determined by taking the total of all Benefits Checks issued by the
H&W Pool to Medical Providers for each Member’s Eligible Employees and
Dependents in the preceding month and dividing that total by the total number
of each Member’s Eligible Employees (not including Dependents) in the preceding
month.
(c)
Third, each Member’s Claims Frequency Ratio (determined
in sub ¶ (b) above) will be divided by the H&W Pool’s Average Claims
Frequency Ratio (determined in sub ¶ (a) above).
(d)
Next, to convert Members’ Ratios to relative
percentages, the number yielded for each Member under sub ¶ (c) above will be
divided by the total of all Members’ Claims Frequency Ratios, and the resulting
percentage shall be deemed a Member’s Claims Frequency Factor.
(e)
Finally, the Member’s Claims Frequency Factor will be
multiplied times 30% of the preceding month’s Shared H&W Costs. The resulting dollar amount for each Member
shall be such Member’s H&W Claims Experience Allocation, the first of the
two Formula Components that establish the amount of each Member’s H&W
Assessment Share portion of its Monthly H&W Assessment.
Example: Assume a total of Shared H&W Costs (i.e.,
all H&W Pool Operational Costs, but excluding all Members’ Direct H&W
Claims Costs) for the preceding month in the amount of $11,350. Further assume that the total number of
Benefits Checks issued to Medical Providers for payment of H&W Claims for
all Members’ Eligible Employees and Dependents in the preceding month was 344,
and the total number of such Checks issued in the preceding month for Member
A’s Eligible Employees and Dependents was 143.
Further assume that the total number of Eligible Employees for all
Members in the preceding month was 192, and that the total number of Eligible
Employees for Member A in the preceding month was 70.
Based
on the above numbers, calculation of Member A’s “H&W Claims Experience
Assessment Allocation” with respect to the $11,350 of Shared H&W Costs from
the preceding month is as follows:
(a)
The Average Claims Frequency Ratio for the H&W Pool
is 1.79 (i.e. 344 Benefits Checks issued for all Members’ Employees and Dependents
divided by 192, the total number of all Members’ Eligible Employees).
(b)
The Claims Frequency Ratio for Member A is 2.04 (i.e.
143 Benefits Checks issued for Member A’s Eligible Employees and Dependents
divided by 70, the number of Member A’s Eligible Employees).
(c)
Next, Member A’s Claims Frequency Ratio is divided by
the H&W Pool’s Average Claims Frequency Ratio yielding the number 1.13966
(1.79 from sub¶ (a) above divided by 2.04 from sub¶ (b) above).
(d)
Member A’s Claims Frequency Factor is the relative
percentage Member A’s Claims Frequency Ratio bears to the total of the Ratios
of all Members, or .173 (assuming the total of all Members’ Claims Frequency
Ratios is 6.58, the 1.13966 calculated under sub¶ (c) above, divided by 6.58,
yields .173).
(e)
The thirty percent (30%) Assessment Allocation for all
Members for H&W Claims Experience is determined by multiplying thirty
percent (30%) times the $11,350 amount of Shared H&W Costs for the
preceding month, yielding $3,405.
Therefore, Member A’s H&W Claims Experience Assessment Allocation is
determined by multiplying Member A’s Claims Frequency Factor of .173
(calculated under sub¶ (d) above) times $3,405 (30% of the Shared H&W
Costs), and Member A’s Assessment Share for this Formula Component is $589.06.
2.2 Eligible Employee Assessment Allocation at 70%. Seventy percent (70%) of the amount of the
Shared H&W Costs paid in, or otherwise allocable to, the preceding month of
H&W Pool operations shall be assessed to the H&W Pool Members under the
H&W General Assessment Formula based on the number of Eligible Employees
each Member employed in the preceding month.
The Formula steps for deriving this Formula Component are as follows:
(a)
First, each Member’s Eligible Employee Factor will be
determined by dividing the number of each Member’s Eligible Employees in the
preceding month by the total of all Eligible Employees for all Members in the
preceding month.
(b)
Second, each Member’s Eligible Employee Factor (as
determined in sub ¶ (a) above) will then be multiplied times seventy percent
(70%) of the preceding month’s Shared H&W Costs. The resulting dollar amount for each Member
shall be such Member’s Eligible Employee Assessment Allocation, the second of
the two Formula Components that establish the amount of each Member’s H&W
Assessment Share portion of its Monthly H&W Assessment.
Example: Assume a total of Shared H&W Costs (i.e.
all H&W Pool Operational Costs, but excluding all Members’ Direct H&W
Claims Costs) for the preceding month in the amount of $11,350. Further assume that the total number of
Eligible Employees (not including Dependents) for all Members of the H&W
Pool in the preceding month was 192, and that the total number of Eligible
Employees (not including Dependents) for Member A for the preceding month was
70. Member A’s Eligible Employee Factor
will then be determined by dividing the number of Member A’s Eligible Employees
in the preceding month by the total number of all Eligible Employees for all
Members in the preceding month (i.e., 70 ÷192 = 36.45%). Finally, the seventy percent (70%) Assessment
Allocation for Eligible Employees is determined by multiplying seventy percent
(70%) times the $11,350 amount of Shared H&W Costs for the preceding month,
yielding $7,945. Therefore, Member A’s
Eligible Employees Assessment Allocation is determined by multiplying Member
A’s Eligible Employee Factor of 36.45% times $7,945 (70% of the Shared H&W
Costs), and Member A’s Assessment Share for this Formula Component is
$2,8965.95.
2.3.
Determination of The Amount of
a Member’s Monthly H&W Assessment. A Member’s H&W Assessment Share of the
preceding month’s Shared H&W Costs shall be the total of the two amounts
determined for the Member under ¶¶ 2.1 and 2.2 above (i.e., a Member’s H&W
Claims Experience Assessment Allocation, plus that Member’s Eligible Employee
Assessment Allocation). The amount of
the Member’s H&W Assessment Share, plus the amount of the Member’s Direct
H&W Claims Costs paid in the preceding month, shall be the amount of the
Member’s current Monthly H&W Assessment.
Example: With respect to Member A in the Examples in
¶¶ 2.1 and 2.2 above, assuming Member A’s Direct H&W Claims Costs for
the preceding month was $4,824, Member A’s current Monthly H&W Assessment
would be $8,309.02 (i.e., $4,824 of Direct H&W Claims Costs, plus $589.07
for Member A’s H&W Claims Experience Assessment Allocation, plus $2,895.95
for Member A’s Eligible Employee Assessment Allocation).
3.1.
Basic Function and Operation
of Stop Loss Points.
3.1.1.
H&W Pool Stop Loss Points. The H&W Pool has two (2) Stop Loss
Points. When either Stop Loss Point is
reached, H&W Claims that otherwise would be paid by the Member (as Direct
H&W Claims Costs) or by the H&W Pool (as Shared H&W Claims) are
instead paid by Stop Loss Insurance. The
“H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss” is the total dollar amount of Stop Loss
Recognized H&W Claims at which point further payments by the H&W Pool
for the H&W Claims of any and all Members are thereafter paid by the Stop
Loss Insurance. The “H&W Pool
Individual Stop Loss” is any circumstance in which a dollar amount is
established with a Stop Loss Carrier at which any further payments the H&W
Pool would otherwise make in connection with an H&W Claim and/or an
Eligible Employee or Dependant are instead covered by Stop Loss Insurance, even
though the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss has not been reached. The H&W Pool Individual Stop Loss may be
based on a specified dollar amount per H&W Claim, or per a particular
Covered H&W Claim for the balance of the Stop Loss Policy Year, or per
H&W Claims for a particular Eligible Employee for the balance of the Stop
Loss Policy Year, or per some other basis as determined by the Stop Loss
Carrier and agreed to by the Fund. The
dollar amounts of both of these H&W Pool Stop Loss Points will be
established by agreement between the Fund and the Stop Loss Carrier and
normally will be redetermined or reset at the end of
each Stop Loss Policy Year.
3.1.2.
Member Stop Loss Points. Each Member of the H&W Pool also has two
(2) Stop Loss Points. When expenditures
by the H&W Pool for a Member’s Direct H&W Claims Costs reaches either
Stop Loss Point, H&W Claims that otherwise would be paid by the Member as
Direct H&W Claims Costs are instead assessed to all Members (except the
Member that has reached the Stop Loss Point) as Shared H&W Claims under the
H&W General Assessment Formula. The
“Member Aggregate Stop Loss” is the total dollar amount at which any further
payments by the H&W Pool on H&W Claims by a Member’s Eligible Employees
and Dependents shall constitute Shared H&W Claims and shall be reimbursed
to the H&W Pool by Assessment of all Members (except the Member that has
reached its Aggregate Stop Loss Point) under the H&W General Assessment
Formula, rather than being passed through to the Member as “Direct H&W
Claims Costs.” The “Member Individual
Stop Loss” is the total dollar amount at which any further payments the H&W
Pool makes in connection with an H&W Claim or an Eligible Employee or
Dependent are thereafter treated as a Shared H&W Claim and shall be
reimbursed to the H&W Pool by Assessment of all Members (except the Member
that has reached its Individual Stop Loss Point) under the General Assessment
Formula, rather than being passed through to the Member as “Direct H&W
Claims Costs.” The basis for calculating
and applying the Member Individual Stop Loss shall be the same as that employed
by the Stop Loss Carrier for determining when the H&W Pool Individual Stop
Loss has been reached (See ¶ 3.1.1 above).
The dollar amount of each of these Member Stop Loss Points shall be
established according to ¶¶ 3.2.3 and 3.24, respectively, below.
3.2.
Calculation of Member Stop
Loss Points.
3.2.1.
Total of Members’ Aggregate
Stop Loss Points Shall Equal the H&W Pool Stop Loss. The amounts of Members’ respective Aggregate
Stop Loss Points are determined in the first instance by the amount of the
H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss. The
total of all Members’ Aggregate Stop Loss Points must equal the amount of the
H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss so that, when money spent by the H&W Pool
on all Members’ H&W Claims equals the H&W Pool’s Aggregate Stop Loss
Point, the Stop Loss Insurance will begin paying for all subsequent H&W
Claims.
3.2.2.
Formulas for Determining Member
Stop Loss Points Are Weighted Based on the Number of Employees and Dependents
Receiving H&W Coverage. To
more accurately tailor the amounts of a Member’s Stop Loss Points to the risk
posed by the number of Eligible Employees and Dependents receiving H&W
Coverage through that Member, the Employees insured through that Member shall
be divided into the three (3) Employee Demographic Categories: (a) an Eligible
Employee with No-Dependent Coverage; (b) an Eligible Employee with
One-Dependent Coverage; and (c) an Eligible Employee with Two (or more)
Dependent Coverage.
3.2.3.
Calculation of a Member’s
Aggregate Stop Loss Based on Member’s Employee Demographics. A Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss shall be
calculated as follows:
(a)
The total of all of the Members’ Eligible Employees
with No-Dependent Coverage shall be determined.
(b)
The total of all of the Members’ Eligible Employees
with One-Dependent Coverage shall be determined and then multiplied by 2, which
determines the number of Eligible Insureds in this Category.
(c)
The total of all of the Members’ Eligible Employees
with Two-Dependent Coverage shall be determined and then multiplied by 3, which
determines the number of Eligible Insureds in this Category.
(d)
Next, the percentage that the number of Eligible
Insureds in each of the three H&W Pool’s Employee Demographic Categories is
of the total in all Demographic Categories for all Members shall be calculated
by dividing the total of the Eligible Insureds in each of the H&W Pool
Employee Demographic Categories (as determined in sub¶s (a) – (c) above) by the
of Eligible Insureds for all H&W Pool Employee Demographic Categories. This yields the weighted percentage of risk
each H&W Pool Employee Demographic Category poses vis-à-vis the total risk
of the H&W Pool.
(e)
Next, each of the three percentages established for
each of the H&W Pool’s Employee Demographic Categories determined pursuant
to sub¶(d) above shall be multiplied times the amount of the H&W Pool
Aggregate Stop Loss. As a result, the
total of the dollar amounts of each of the three (3) H &W Pool Employee
Demographic Categories will equal the dollar amount of the H&W Pool’s
Aggregate Stop Loss. This will ensure
that the H&W Pool will be able to assess and collect sufficient monies from
all Members to pay for all H&W Claims in the Coverage Year up to the point
where the Stop Loss Insurance takes over payment of all further H&W Claims.
(f)
Next, the process set forth in sub¶¶s (a), (b) and (c)
above will be repeated for each Member with respect to its own Employee
Demographic Categories to determine the weighted number of Eligible Insureds in
each of the Member’s Employee Demographic Categories (i.e., the Formula
will total a Member’s Eligible Employees with No-Dependent, One-Dependent and
Two–Dependent Coverage, and multiply the number of Eligible Employees in each
Demographic Category by the factors of 1, 2 and 3, respectively).
(g)
Then, the total Eligible Insureds in each Employee
Demographic Category for each Member will be divided by the total Eligible
Insureds in each of the corresponding Demographic Categories for all Members of
the H&W Pool derived from the calculations made in sub¶¶s (a), (b) and (c)
above.
(h)
Finally, each of the three Ratios in each of the three
Employee Demographic Categories for each Member derived from the calculations
set forth in sub¶ (g) above shall be multiplied times the dollar amounts
calculated for the three corresponding H&W Pool Employee Demographic
Categories under sub¶ (e) above. The
total of the three resulting dollar amounts in a Member’s three Employee
Demographic Categories derived in the sub¶
(h) above shall be the amount of that Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss.
Example: Assume Member A has 15, 15 and 40 Eligible
Employees in the three respective Employee Demographic Categories (a) – (c), and
also assume that the totals of all Members’ Eligible Employees in each of the
respective Employee Demographic Categories (a) – (c) are 49, 54 and 84. Member A’s Aggregate Stop Loss Point shall be
calculated as follows:
(a)
The total of all Members’ Eligible Employees with
No-Dependent Coverage is 49.
(b)
The total of all Members’ Eligible Employees with
One-Dependent Coverage is 59, and multiplied by 2, is 118 Eligible Insureds.
(c)
The total of all Members’ Eligible Employees with Two-Dependent
Coverage is 84, and multiplied by 3, is 252 Eligible Insureds.
(d)
The percentage that each of the three H&W Pool
Employee Demographic Categories is as to all Eligible Insureds for all Members,
49, 118 and 252, respectively, are divided by 419 (i.e. the number of all
Eligible Insureds for all Members) yielding: 11.69% of the Eligible Insureds
have No-Dependent Coverage; 28.16% have One-Dependent Coverage; and 60.14% have
Two-Dependent Coverage.
(e)
The amount of money that must be collected from each H&W
Pool Employee Demographic Category is then determined by multiplying each of
the percentages derived in sub¶ (d) above times the amount of the H&W
Pools’ Aggregate Stop Loss (assumed for this Example to be $907,668), yielding
$106,147.32, $255,620.16 and $545,900.56 which must be collected, respectively,
from the Eligible Insureds’ in each Employee Demographic Category.
(f)
Then, the number of Eligible Employees in each Employee
Demographic Category for each Member shall be weighed to determine the number of
Eligible Insureds in each Category in the same manner as for the H&W Pool
in ¶¶s (a) – (c) above, yielding 15, 30 and 120 Eligible Insureds, respectively, for Member A.
(g)
Next, the relative percentage that the number of
Eligible Insureds in each of Member A’s Employee Demographic Categories is as
to all Eligible Insureds of such Member is determined. Member A has 30.61% of Eligible Insureds with
No-Dependent Coverage (i.e. 15 divided by 49); 25.42% with One-Dependent
Coverage (i.e. 30 divided by 118), and 47.62% with Two Dependent Coverage (i.e.
120 divided by 252).
(h)
Finally, each of the percentages derived for Member A
in sub¶ (g) above (i.e., 30.61%, 25.42% and 47.62%) will be multiplied times
the dollar amounts that must be collected from the Eligible Insureds in each
H&W Pool Employee Demographic Category determined in sub¶ (e) above,
yielding $32,494.07 (i.e. 30.61% X $106,147.32), $64,988.14 (i.e. 25.42% X
$255,620.16), and $259,952.60 (i.e. 47.62% X $545,900.56), respectively.
The total of the dollar amounts in each of Member A’s
Employee Demographic Categories is Member A’s Aggregate Stop Loss Point (for
the preceding month), or $357,434.81 (i.e. $32,494.07 + $64,988.14 +
$259,952.60 = $357,434.81).
3.2.4.
Calculation of a Member’s
Individual Stop Loss Point. At all times, the basis used by the Stop
Loss Carrier for measuring how and when the H&W Pool has reached its
Individual Stop Loss shall also be used by the H&W Pool to calculate and
determine how and when Members have reached their Individual Stop Loss
Points. The Administrator shall provide
H&W Pool Members with reasonable notice and explanation of any changes in
the basis upon which the Stop Loss Carrier determines how and when the H&W
Pool’s, and therefore the Members’, Individual Stop Loss Points are
calculated. A Members’ Individual Stop
Loss Point shall be as determined under ¶¶s 3.2.4.1 below; provided that if the
Primary ISL Method Cross Check in ¶3.2.4.2 below is not satisfied, then a
Members’ Individual Stop Loss Point shall be calculated according to ¶3.2.4.3
below.
3.2.4.1.
“Primary ISL Method” to
Determine a Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point. The Primary ISL Method
for calculating a Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point involves exactly the same
step as set fort in sub¶s (a)-(d), (f) and (g) of ¶3.2.3 above for determining
a Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss. With the
numbers derived from the sub¶s (a)-(d), (f) and (g) above, a Member’s
Individual Stop Loss Point under the Primary ISL Method is as follows:
(h)
The percentage for each of the three H&W Pool Demographic
Categories determined in sub¶ (d) above shall be multiplied times the
percentages derived in the corresponding Employee Demographic Categories for
the Member in sub¶ (g) above.
Example. Thus, for Member A in the Examples used
above: 11.69% x 30.61% = 3.578%; 28.16%
x 25.42 = 7.158%; and 60.14% x 47.62% = 28.638%.
(i)
Finally, each of the three percentages derived under
sub¶ (h) above shall be multiplied times the amount of the H&W Pool’s
Individual Stop Loss. The total of the
three resulting dollar amounts shall be the Member’s Individual Stop Loss
Point; provided that the Primary ISL Method Cross Check in ¶3.2.4.2 below is
satisfied.
Example. Assuming that the H&W Pool’s Individual
Stop Loss is $60,000, Member A’s Individual Stop Loss Point based on the
percentages derived in sub¶ (h) would be $23,624.40 (i.e., the total of 3.578%
x $60,000 = $2,146.80; 7.158% x $60,000 = $4,294.86; and 28.638% x $60,000 =
$17,182.80).
3.2.4.2.
Primary ISL Method Cross Check. If a Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point calculated
under ¶3.2.4.1 above, multiplied times the number of a Member’s Eligible
Employees, results in a dollar amount that is equal to or greater than the
amount of that Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss, then that Member’s Individual Stop
Loss Point as calculated by the Primary ISL Method in ¶3.2.4.1 above shall be
applied. If the resulting dollar amount
is less than the Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss, then the Alternate ISL Method in
¶3.4.2.3 below shall apply.
Example. Member A’ Aggregate Stop Loss is $357,434.81
(see ¶3.2.3 (h) above). Member A’s
Individual Stop Loss calculated under the Primary ISL Method in ¶3.2.4.1 is
$23,624.40. Multiplying $23,624.40 times
70, the number of Member A’s Eligible Employees, yields $1,653,708. Because this number is greater than Member
A’s $357,434.81 Aggregate Stop Loss, Member A’s Individual Stop Loss Point
shall remain at $23,624.40 under the Primary ISL Method.
3.2.4.3.
Alternate ISL Method to
Determine a Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point. If the Primary ISL Method Cross Check in
¶3.4.2.2 above is not satisfied, this Alternate ISL Method shall determine the
amount of a Member’s Individual Stop Loss Point, which shall be the dollar
amount resulting from dividing the Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss by the number
of that Member’s Eligible Employees.
Example: Assuming that Member A’s Individual Stop Loss
calculated under the Primary ISL Method did not satisfy the Cross Check in
¶3.2.4.2 above (which is not the case), the Alternate ISL Method would be
applied to Member A as follows: Member
A’s Aggregate Stop Loss of $357,434.81 is divided by 70, the number of Member
A’s Eligible Employees, which yields an Individual Stop Loss Point for Member A
of $5,106.21. (However, since Member A’s
Individual Stop Loss under the Primary ISL Method did satisfy the Cross Check,
the step of calculating Member A’s Individual Stop Loss under this Alternate
ISL Method would not have occurred).
3.3.
H&W Claims That Accrue
Towards Satisfying a Member’s Stop Loss Points.
3.3.1.
Payments that Count Toward
Satisfying a Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss. The following H&W Claims payments count
towards satisfying a Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss:
(a) All Direct H&W
Claims Costs paid by the H&W Pool to be reimbursed by such Member to the
H&W Pool;
(b) The total of the
portions of such Member’s H&W Assessment Shares that relate to paying for
Shared H&W Claims (except for the Shared H&W Claims that originate from
such Member’s own Eligible Employees and Dependents); and
(c) Any other types of
expenditures incurred in connection with such Member’s H&W Claims that are
recognized by the Stop Loss Carrier as counting towards satisfying the H&W
Pool Aggregate Stop Loss. The total of the payments made by or on behalf of a
Member under sub-¶¶s (a) through (c) above shall be deemed to be such Member’s
“Accrued Stop Loss Payments”.
3.3.2.
Effect of a Member reaching
its Aggregate Stop Loss Point.
Except as provided otherwise in ¶ 4 below, a Member that reaches
its Member Aggregate Stop Loss Point during an H&W Coverage Year shall not
thereafter be obligated to reimburse the H&W Pool as Direct H&W Claims
Costs the amounts of payments made for H&W Claims by the Member’s Eligible
Employees and Dependents for the remainder of such Coverage Year, nor for its
Assessment Share of the costs of other Members’ Shared H&W Claims. All payments on H&W Claims by such
Member’s Eligible Employees and Dependents thereafter shall be treated as
Shared H&W Claims and the cost thereof shall be assessed to all other
Members of the H&W Pool under the H&W General Assessment Formula. For the remainder of the H&W Coverage
Year, the Member that reached its Aggregate Stop Loss Point shall continue to
be obligated to pay its Assessment Share of all H&W Pool Operational Costs
(except for H&W Claims Costs), and therefore, such Member’s H&W
Assessment Shares shall be determined under the H&W General Assessment
Formula after excluding all H&W Claims Costs thereafter paid by the H&W
Pool for all Members, including the Member that reached its Aggregate Stop Loss
Point. In the event that all Members reach their respective Member Aggregate
Stop Loss Points prior to the end of the Stop Loss Policy Year, the amount of
the Accrued Stop Loss Payments for all Members of the H&W Pool shall be
reset to zero, as if it was the beginning of a Stop Loss Policy Year, effective
as of the date the last Member reached its Aggregate Stop Loss Point.
3.3.3.
Payments That Count Towards
Satisfying a Member’s Individual Stop Loss. All monies paid by the H&W Pool on a
particular H&W Claim and/or for an Eligible Employee or Dependent of a
Member, or on some other basis where the amounts of such payments are
recognized by the Stop Loss Carrier as counting towards satisfying the H&W
Pool’s Individual Stop Loss, shall be accrued by the H&W Pool toward that
Member’s Individual Stop Loss for the Coverage Year. All such amounts shall also be accrued
towards such Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss for the same period.
3.3.4.
Effect of a Member Reaching
its Individual Stop Loss. Once
the total of the payments made by the H&W Pool on a particular H&W
Claim and/or for a particular Eligible Employee or Dependent of a Member (or on
some other basis recognized by the Stop Loss Carrier as counting toward the
H&W Pool’s Individual Stop Loss) reaches that Member’s Individual Stop Loss
Point, any further payments made on such Claim shall be treated as a Shared
H&W Claim and shall be assessed to all Members (except for the Member that
has reached its Individual Stop Loss Point) under the H&W General Assessment
Formula. Thereafter, such payments shall
continue to be treated as a Shared H&W Claim until the total amount that
has been paid thereon equals the H&W Pool’s Individual Stop Loss, at which
point any further such payments required shall be paid by, or reimbursed to the
H&W Pool by, the Stop Loss Insurance.
All other Members’ payments on their H&W Assessment Shares relating
to such Shared H&W Claim shall be accrued toward each such Member’s
respective Aggregate Stop Loss Point.
The Member that reached its Individual Stop Loss Point shall continue to
pay its own Direct H&W Claim Costs (unless and until the Member reaches its
Member Aggregate Stop Loss) and its H&W Assessment Share of all other
Members’ Shared H&W Claims.
4.
H&W Assessments in Excess
of Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss.
4.1.
Determination of When H&W Pool Has Reached the Pool
Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss and Effect of Same. The H&W Pool will be deemed to have
reached the Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss Point when the money spent by
the H&W Pool on all Members’ H&W Claims in a Coverage Year, including
H&W Pool Recognized Claims, equals the amount of the H&W Pool’s
Aggregate Stop Loss Point, even if, at the time this occurs, one or more
Members have not yet reached their Member Aggregate Stop Loss Points. All H&W Claims paid by the H&W Pool
after reaching the Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss Point (i.e., all
“Post-Stop Loss H&W Claims”) shall be treated as Shared H&W Costs and
shall be assessed to all Members, if necessary, including the Members whose
Employees or Dependents generated the respective H&W Claims, under the
H&W General Assessment Formula.
4.2.
Determination of When H&W
Pool Has Reached its H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss, Effects of Same,
Additional H&W Assessments and Refunds.
4.2.1.
Further H&W Claims
Incurred are Responsibility of Stop Loss Carrier. When payments by the H&W Pool on H&W
Claims reach the Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss Point, and if such Claims
are also Stop Loss Recognized Claims, it will become the responsibility of the
Stop Loss Carrier thereafter to pay, or reimburse the H&W Pool for, any
further H&W Claims for the remainder of the Coverage Year/Stop Loss Policy
Year. If some of such Claims do not
constitute Stop Loss Recognized Claims and the Stop Loss Carrier requires
additional payments by the H&W Pool on H&W Claims before agreeing that
the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss has been reached, such additional Claims
shall be assessed as Shared H&W Claims (See also, ¶ 4.1 above). Notwithstanding the H&W Pool reaching the
Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss Point, all Members shall continue to be
responsible for paying their H&W Assessment Shares of H&W Pool
Operational Costs, including all H&W Claims Costs incurred in the remainder
of the Coverage Year, as provided in ¶ 4.2.2 below.
4.2.2.
Members are Subject to H&W
Assessments for H&W Claims as Shared H&W Claims Even After Reaching
H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss Point.
Paragraph 4.2.1 above identified circumstances necessitating further
H&W Assessments of the Members to pay H&W Claims despite the fact that
the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss Point has been reached (i.e., where the
Stop Loss Carrier refuses to consider certain H&W Claims payments as
counting toward satisfaction of the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss, and
requires further H&W Claims payments by the H&W Pool to trigger the
Stop Loss Coverage). Other circumstances
may occur where it is necessary to assess Members even beyond the H&W Pool
reaching the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss Point (i.e., where there is an
“indemnity” versus “pay on behalf of” Stop Loss Policy; or where the Stop Loss
Carrier requires an accounting to establish that the H&W Pool Aggregate
Stop Loss has been satisfied before paying further H&W Claims; or where the
Stop Loss Policy contains terms restricting Claims payments or reimbursements
during the Stop Loss Policy claims runout period). Therefore, notwithstanding satisfaction of
the H&W Pool Aggregate Stop Loss, and triggering of the Stop Loss Coverage,
all Members shall be subject to further H&W Assessments for Post-Stop-Loss
H&W Claims and H&W Pool Operational Costs.
4.2.3.
Refund to Members of
Post-Stop-Loss H&W Assessments.
Upon and to the extent of payment or reimbursement to the H&W Pool
by the Stop Loss Carrier for the Post-Stop-Loss H&W Claims the H&W Pool
paid in a Stop Loss Policy Year, the H&W Pool shall refund the
reimbursement money to the Members of the H&W Pool, without interest, in
the same amounts that each such Member contributed under its H&W Assessment
Shares for such Post-Stop-Loss H&W Claims.
5.
Procedures for Resolving
“Debatable” H&W Claims, for Permitting “Allowed” H&W Claims, and the
Effect of Resolution of Same re H&W General Assessment Formula.
5.1.
Debatable H&W Claim. A “Debatable H&W Claim” is an H&W
Claim for which H&W Coverage is not clearly provided for, and is not
clearly precluded by, the terms of the applicable Coverage Booklet and the
SIA. If a Member (but not an Employee on
his/her own) believes a particular H&W Claim that previously has been
denied H&W Coverage through exhaustion of all Appeal Procedures (see
§ I, ¶ 17) is a “Debatable H&W Claim,” the Member may thereafter
apply to the Administrative Committee requesting that the denied H&W Claim
be treated as a “Recognized H&W Claim” (either as a “Stop Loss Recognized
H&W Claim” or as a “Pool Recognized H&W Claim”).
5.2.
“Recognized” or “Allowed”
H&W Claims. A Member’s
request that a denied H&W Claim be treated as a “Recognized H&W Claim”
shall be resolved as follows:
5.2.1.
If Stop Loss Carrier Would
Count Payments on the Denied H&W Claim Towards the H&W Pool’s Stop Loss
Points, the Claim shall be Treated as a “Stop-Loss Recognized H&W Claim”. If the Stop Loss Carrier agrees to recognize
payment by the H&W Pool on the denied H&W Claim as counting towards
satisfaction of the H&W Pool’s Aggregate (and/or Individual) Stop Loss
Points, the denied Claim shall be deemed a “Stop-Loss Recognized H&W Claim”
and shall be treated as a Covered H&W Claim as if it had not been denied in
the first instance. All payments on such
H&W Claim shall accrue toward such Member’s Aggregate and Individual Stop
Loss Points.
5.2.2.
If Stop Loss Carrier Will Not
Count Payment on the Denied H&W Claim Towards the H&W Pool’s Stop Loss
Points, the Claim May or May Not be Deemed a “Pool Recognized H&W Claim”. If the Stop Loss Carrier will not recognize
payment by the H&W Pool on the denied H&W Claim as counting towards
satisfaction of the H&W Pool’s Aggregate (and/or Individual) Stop Loss
Points, and if the Member still desires that the denied H&W Claim receive
H&W Coverage and be paid by the H&W Pool, then:
5.2.2.1.
Pool Recognized H&W Claim. If the Administrative Committee concludes
that it is truly reasonably debatable whether the denied H&W Claim is
entitled to H&W Coverage under the terms of the applicable Coverage Booklet
and the SIA, the Administrative Committee shall denominate the Claim as a “Pool
Recognized H&W Claim.” If the Claim
is deemed a “Pool Recognized H&W Claim,” then it shall be treated for all
purposes, including whether the Claim would have been accounted for as a Direct
& H&W Claims Cost or a Shared H&W Claim, as if it had never been
denied. The amounts paid by the H&W
Pool on such Claim shall be counted toward the Member’s Aggregate and
Individual Stop Loss Points, and against the Pool Recognized Stop Loss Point;
provided, however, that all “Post-Stop-Loss H&W Claims” shall be treated as
Shared H&W Costs, and all Members, including the Member that requested
treatment of the denied Claim as a Pool Recognized H&W Claim, shall pay
their Assessment Shares thereof under the H&W General Assessment Formula,
even if the Stop Loss Carrier does not agree that the H&W Pool Aggregate
Stop Loss Point has been reached because it does not count one or more Pool
Recognized H&W Claims as applying toward satisfaction of the H&W Pool
Aggregate Stop Loss.
5.2.2.2.
Allowed H&W Claims. If the Administrative Committee concludes
that H&W Coverage for the denied H&W Claim is not reasonably debatable
and that the Claim is not entitled to H&W Coverage, the Administrative
Committee shall denominate the Claim as an “Allowed H&W Claim.” If the Claim is deemed an “Allowed H&W
Claim,” then it shall be treated as a Direct H&W Claim Cost to the Member
and shall not be counted either toward such Member’s Aggregate Stop Loss or its
Individual Stop Loss, or toward the Pool Recognized Aggregate Stop Loss Point.
5.2.3.
Member’s Right to Seek H&W
Coverage as “Allowed H&W Claim” at any Time.
5.2.3.1.
“Allowed H&W Claims”
without Exhaustion of Appeal Procedures.
At any time after the initial denial of H&W Coverage for a
particular H&W Claim, and regardless of whether the Appeal Procedures have
been exhausted with respect to the Claim, the Member may submit a written
request to the Administrative Committee to treat the Claim as an “Allowed
H&W Claim.” Upon receiving such
request, the Administrative Committee shall deem the Claim to be an “Allowed
H&W Claim,” and it shall thereafter be treated under all circumstances as a
Direct H&W Claims Cost to the Member making the request, and payments thereon
by the H&W Pool shall not be counted either toward such Member’s Aggregate
Stop Loss or its Individual Stop Loss, or toward the Pool Recognized Stop Loss
Point. Any Member requiring and
receiving treatment of a denied H&W Claim as an Allowed H&W Claim thereby
agrees to indemnify and hold the Fund, the H&W Pool, the Administrative
Committee and the Administrator harmless for any liability that arises in any
way from the Allowed H&W Claim, and if such Member is also a Member of the
Liability Pool, the Member further agrees that any such liability shall not be
Covered by the Liability Pool.
5.2.3.2.
“Allowed H&W Claim”
Pending Exhaustion of Appeal Procedures.
If a Member that has invoked and is pursuing its rights under the Appeal
Procedures with respect to a denied H&W Claim wishes to have the Claim paid
by the H&W Pool pending a final determination of H&W Coverage under the
Appeal Procedures, the Member may make written request to the Administrative
Committee to treat the Claim as an “Allowed H&W Claim” in the interim, in
which case the H&W Pool will pay the Claim as a “Direct H&W Claims
Cost” for the Member. If, as a result of
the Appeal Procedures, H&W Coverage is provided for the previously denied
Claim, then the Claim will be treated as if it had not been denied at the time
presented, and if appropriate, re-characterized and re-accounted for as a
Shared H&W Claim. If the appeal
results in affirmance of the denial, the Claim shall
be treated as an “Allowed H&W Claim.”
6.
Former Members. After the effective date of a Former Member’s
Withdrawal from the H&W Pool, the Former Member’s obligations with respect
to the H&W General Assessment Formula, and its Incurred H&W Claims and
Extended Coverage H&W Claims, shall be as set forth in ¶ 20.2.2, which deals
with the rights and obligations of a Former Member.
7.
New Members. The H&W General Assessment Formula shall
be applied so that, for a period of six (6) years following its Date of
Membership, the New Member’s H&W Assessment Share is based only on H&W Claims
that were Incurred after the New Member’s Date of Membership.